RIM missed earnings, guidance and gross margins in the latest quarter. The only positive that I could find was the higher expected phone shipment ("27% to 37%") in the coming quarter, and it was mostly due to their over-stuffing the channel in the previous quarters. The new BlackBerry 7 smartphones, which they touted so much in the conference call, are part of "the transition to QNX-based smartphones". That is real comforting for their long-term customers. All their future hopes are hanging on QNX-based smartphones, which are expected in 2012.
The main negative surprise for me was their paltry 200,000 PlayBook shipments, which were down 60% from previous quarter. Clearly, they were no match for iPads. The other downer was that they spent $780 million in acquiring part of the Nortel patent portfolio through a consortium, in which Apple is a part of. Since RIM needs to knock-down Apple and destroy the Android camp in order to compete, I just don't see the point of spending nearly a billion dollar to buy a bag of patents, which are useful for leaders to defend themselves against copycats. Does RIM have any copycats today? This is the trouble with troubled companies, which tend to throw good money after bad. HP (HPQ) just illustrated how they swallowed and choked on Palm.
RIM used to be a very successful and well-managed company. In many ways, it still is. I first encountered the stock at my old shop where my tech analyst was using a cool BlackBerry instead of a pager in the late 90s. They were the first major company to embrace message centric devices with full keyboards to counter then popular Palm OS-enabled devices using handwriting for input. RIM was able to dominate the personal digital assistants (PDAs) market, and later on the smartphone market. As a result, Palm was pushed to the brink of bankruptcy before HP swallowed it and now is trying to puke it out. I was a RIM customer and investor for years until Apple's introduction of iPhones in 2007 when I realized how great the iPhone was! The trouble at RIM has little to do with RIM itself, but everything to do with the iPhone. What Apple did to RIM is similar to what RIM did to Palm. This is just part of the tectonic shift, which happens from time to time in tech, and RIM just happened to be on the sinking side.
Position Recap
Since I recommended shorting 5 RIM Jan. 13 $40 strike calls vs. buying every 1 Apple Jan. 12 $400 strike call on Tuesday, Sept. 13, RIM shared tanked about 20% on the earnings' bust and Apple went up about 4% at the same time. Apple's (AAPL) calls are almost in the money now. RIM shares are 66% away from the $40 strike, quite safe from a takeover bid. As a result, RIM's call premiums got cut in half (from $4 to $2) and Apple's gained 18% from ($26 to $30.5). It was a good start and we should consider camping out for the new iPhone 5s.
at seekingAlpha.com:
http://seekingalpha.com/article/294308-the-trouble-with-rim-has-little-to-do-with-rim-itself
No comments:
Post a Comment